Too Good to Be True: A Love Letter to Romance and Reinvention
The clock strikes 2025, and the literary world is already abuzz. HarperCollins Publishers India has set the tone for a year that promises a revival of heartstrings and hope. Enter Prajakta Koli—actor, creator, and now author—with her debut romance novel Too Good to Be True. A title that seems to echo the aspirations of readers yearning for that spark of magic in an increasingly pragmatic world.
What makes this book more than just another romantic escapade is its very essence—rooted in modern love, friendship, and the messy, glorious journey of self-discovery. Like the author herself, the narrative is playful yet profound, accessible yet layered. Prajakta Koli, also known as MostlySane to millions across the digital realm, doesn’t just write a story; she crafts an experience—a tapestry woven with emotion, wit, and relatability.
The Symphony of Love and Literature
The novel’s protagonist, Avani, is an avatar of every romantic’s secret yearning. She works at a bookstore, the kind of place where stories whisper from the shelves, and every spine promises a journey. It’s here that she encounters Aman, a character who seems sculpted from the ideals of every romance novel she’s ever cherished. A man who is equal parts enigmatic and endearing, Aman could be the promise of everything Avani has ever wanted—or perhaps, a mirage too good to be true.
This central “will-they-won’t-they” narrative is not a mere trope but an exploration of vulnerability, trust, and the self-sabotaging tendencies we carry into relationships. It’s as much about the reader’s reflection as it is about Avani’s dilemmas.
Adding to the novel’s unique charm is its original soundtrack, Saanvare. Prajakta’s musical foray, in collaboration with Outsky, gives readers a chance to immerse themselves in the emotions of the book even before turning its pages. The harmony of words and music elevates the novel from a solitary experience to a sensory celebration.
Prajakta’s Personal Odyssey
For those who’ve followed Prajakta Koli’s journey, Too Good to Be True is more than a debut—it’s a milestone. She confesses that she never truly believed she could finish a book, yet here she stands, an emblem of perseverance and creativity. “It’s easily one of the most challenging yet most special pieces of content I’ve worked on so far,” she shares.
Her career trajectory mirrors the themes of her novel: daring to dream, embracing reinvention, and finding joy in the process. From YouTube stardom to acting in Netflix’s Mismatched and films like Jugjugg Jeeyo, Prajakta has mastered the art of storytelling across mediums. This book is a natural extension of her evolution—a narrative voice that is as authentic as her digital persona, yet refined with literary depth.
A Publisher’s Dream
Poulomi Chatterjee, Executive Publisher at HarperCollins India, calls the book “a funny, heartwarming, sharply observed and incredibly relatable rom-com.” These words underscore the essence of Too Good to Be True—a book that doesn’t just tell a love story but invites readers to live it.
HarperCollins India’s decision to back Prajakta’s literary debut is a testament to their keen eye for voices that resonate across generations. Romance, after all, is timeless. But in a world constantly redefined by technology, social change, and fleeting attention spans, it takes a fresh, genuine voice to reimagine the genre for today’s readers.
Romance Reimagined for Modern India
What sets Too Good to Be True apart is its unapologetically Indian heart. It’s not about grandiose gestures or impossibly perfect characters. Instead, it’s about real people navigating love amidst the chaos of urban life, societal expectations, and personal insecurities.
Avani’s journey is a mirror to the audience. She is flawed, funny, and fantastically relatable. Aman, meanwhile, is not just a romantic interest but a catalyst for Avani’s growth. Together, they challenge the notion that love is about completion, presenting it instead as a partnership of equals, rooted in mutual respect and understanding.
A Cultural Moment
Prajakta Koli’s leap into the literary world is emblematic of a broader cultural shift. Content creators are no longer confined to the platforms that made them famous. They are writers, actors, entrepreneurs, and changemakers. Prajakta’s work with the Gates Foundation and UNDP highlights her ability to bridge entertainment with impact.
This multidimensional identity seeps into her novel, making it more than a love story. It’s a commentary on how we connect, not just with others but with ourselves. It asks the reader to believe in the transformative power of love while also embracing the beauty of individual growth.
Why This Book Matters
Romance novels are often dismissed as frivolous, yet their impact is profound. They remind us of life’s possibilities, of the resilience of the human heart. In Too Good to Be True, Prajakta captures this essence while anchoring it in contemporary realities.
In an era where relationships are often reduced to swipes and superficiality, this book dares to explore the complexities of genuine connection. It’s a love letter to dreamers, to those who’ve been hurt but still hope, and to everyone navigating the intricate dance of love and self-discovery.
The Power of Stories
As readers pick up Too Good to Be True, they aren’t just buying a book—they’re stepping into a world crafted with care. They’ll laugh, cry, and maybe even hum along to Saanvare.
Prajakta’s debut isn’t just a milestone for her; it’s a moment for her fans, for the romance genre, and for Indian publishing. It’s a reminder that stories—whether told through video, film, or the written word—have the power to unite, inspire, and heal.
So, here’s to Prajakta Koli and her leap into the literary cosmos. May Too Good to Be True find its way into countless hearts, proving that while life may not always be perfect, love—when it arrives—is always worth it.
#TooGoodToBeTrue #PrajaktaKoli #HarperCollinsIndia #ModernRomance #RomComReads #BestsellerBooks #RomanticFiction #MostlySane #IndianAuthors #BookLovers
Poetry Hub 
Hello. Thanks for visiting. I’d love to hear your thoughts! What resonated with you in this piece? Drop a comment below and let’s start a conversation.