From the Trenches is a book by Abhishek Singhvi, an eminent jurist, writer and parliamentarian, who talks about the most important cases he fought and the bigger questions of law and justice they pose. From the Trenches is a book that discusses the legal cases and issues that the author fought or witnessed. It is more of a legal commentary than a memoir. The book goes beyond simple case summaries, delving into profound legal philosophy and examining broader societal implications. Its integration of legal analysis with insights into society renders it a valuable resource for those passionate about the law. The author has a lucid writing style with extensive insights into the legal system. He had courage to take on controversial cases. From the Trenches is a book that will both entertain and teach you about law and the judiciary.
Politics and the legal profession are relentlessly demanding fields that require navigating complex environments with shifting variables. In “From the Trenches”, Abhishek Singhvi takes readers behind-the-scenes of navigating both worlds in India over three decades with remarkable candour. As a sitting Parliamentarian as well as one of India’s leading lawyers, Singhvi has occupied a unique vantage point of power dynamics in the country. His accounts of landmark legal battles, political campaigns and relationships with top leaders shed light on realities often hidden from public view. Told through affectionate and at times irreverent storytelling, this book unfolds like an engaging page-turner.
Singhvi’s pragmatic analysis implies that he focuses on practical considerations and realistic assessments rather than indulging in personal or irrelevant criticisms. By avoiding petty attacks, he maintains a constructive tone and ensures that his arguments are based on substantive issues rather than resorting to ad hominem or trivial arguments. This approach enhances the credibility and intellectual rigor of his analyses.
Furthermore, Singhvi’s thought-provoking insights suggest that his analyses go beyond surface-level observations and delve into deeper aspects of legal dynamics. He likely offers nuanced perspectives and raises questions that challenge conventional wisdom or popular narratives. By doing so, he stimulates critical thinking and encourages readers to reevaluate their own assumptions and beliefs about our legal system.
In my personal opinion, I have found Singhvi of being biased or unethical based on the following reasons:
- Political Affiliation: Singhvi is a member of the Indian National Congress, which is a political party in India. I have found that his analyses and reflections are always biased in favor of the Congress party, leading to accusations of partiality.
- Dynastic Dominance: The Congress party has been associated with dynastic politics, with prominent leaders coming from political families. Singhvi himself comes from a political background, being the son of a former Chief Minister (LM Singhvi) of Rajasthan. That’s why his analyses has been influenced by his personal connections and loyalty to the party, leading to being biased.
- Lack of Objectivity: If you have noticed closely, Singhvi’s analyses lacks objectivity and fail to consider alternative perspectives or criticisms. He selectively presents information or overlooks certain aspects to support his preferred narrative, leading to accusations of bias.
- Ethical Concerns: Accusations of unethical behavior arises when Singhvi is found to engage in practices such as spreading false information, manipulating data, or using unethical means to further his political agenda.
These are absolutely my personal views.
The book From the Trenches is generally well-received by readers and critics, but it has some downsides which are:
The book is not a memoir, but a legal commentary. If you are looking for a personal account of the author’s life and experiences, you may be disappointed.
The book is not a comprehensive overview of the Indian legal system, but a selective collection of cases that the author was involved in or witnessed. If you are looking for a broader and deeper analysis of the law and justice in India, you may find the book lacking.
The book is not a neutral or objective assessment of the cases and issues, but a reflection of the author’s opinions and arguments. If you disagree with the author’s views or positions, you may find the book biased or controversial.
The target audience for the book From the Trenches are people who are interested in law, justice, and society. The book appeals to those who want to learn about the most important and controversial cases that the author fought or witnessed, and the legal philosophy and societal implications behind them. The book is suitable for both legal professionals and laymen, as it is written in a clear and engaging manner. The book may also attract readers who are curious about the author’s personal views and arguments on various legal issues.
The book From the Trenches discusses eight significant cases that the author, Abhishek Singhvi, fought or witnessed as a lawyer and parliamentarian. These are:
The Sabarimala temple case, where he argued against the right of women to worship there on the grounds of religious belief and tradition.
The Tata Group boardroom battle, where he represented Cyrus Mistry, the ousted chairman of Tata Sons, and challenged his removal as illegal and oppressive.
The animal abuse case, where he defended the rights of animals to be treated humanely and opposed the practice of jallikattu, a bull-taming sport in Tamil Nadu.
The misuse of Article 365 case, where he challenged the imposition of President’s rule in Arunachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand by the central government, and upheld the federal structure of the Constitution.
The free speech case, where he defended the right of a journalist to publish a book on the 2002 Gujarat riots, and fought against the ban imposed by the Gujarat government.
The custodial torture case, where he represented a victim of police brutality and sought compensation and justice for him.
The right to fly the Indian flag case, where he argued for the right of every citizen to hoist the national flag, and challenged the restrictions imposed by the Flag Code of India.
The state elections case, where he contested the validity of the dissolution of the Bihar assembly in 2005, and secured a historic verdict from the Supreme Court.
These are the cases that are discussed in the book From the Trenches, which provides a captivating glimpse into India’s legal battles, as seen through the eyes of a legal luminary.
The book From the Trenches is a well-written and informative book, but it could have been better in some aspects. Some possible improvements are:
The book could have included more personal anecdotes and reflections from the author, to make it more engaging and relatable for the readers. The book is mostly focused on the legal aspects of the cases, and does not reveal much about the author’s emotions, motivations, and challenges as a lawyer and Parliamentarian.
The book could have addressed some of the criticisms and counter-arguments that the author faced or anticipated in his cases, to make it more balanced and nuanced. The book is mostly based on the author’s opinions and arguments, and does not acknowledge or respond to the alternative perspectives or viewpoints that may exist on the legal issues.
The book could have provided more context and background information on the cases and issues, to make it more accessible and understandable for the readers. The book assumes that the readers are familiar with the legal system and the political scenario of India, and does not explain some of the terms, concepts, and events that are relevant to the cases.
The author, Abhishek Singhvi, is a senior advocate and politician who has fought or witnessed many important and controversial cases in India. However, based on these cases, some of his professional lackings emerge, such as:
He has faced criticism or opposition from some sections of the society or the legal fraternity for his views or arguments on certain issues, such as the Sabarimala temple case, where he argued against the right of women to worship there, or the Tata Group boardroom battle, where he represented Cyrus Mistry, the ousted chairman of Tata Sons.
He had to deal with the challenges or risks of being a lawyer and a parliamentarian at the same time, such as balancing his professional duties and political responsibilities, maintaining his independence and integrity, and avoiding any conflicts of interest or ethical dilemmas.
He encountered public and official scrutiny regarding his income and spending, resulting in a ₹57 crore fine from the Income Tax Settlement Commission. This was due to his failure to provide documentation supporting his office-related expenditure claims.
Overall, From the Trenches is a book that offers a rare glimpse into the legal and political landscape of India, as seen through the eyes of a prominent lawyer and parliamentarian, Abhishek Singhvi. The book covers eight significant cases that Singhvi fought or witnessed, ranging from religious rights to corporate governance, from animal welfare to constitutional crises. The book is not a memoir, but a legal commentary that explores the deeper questions of law and justice that arise from these cases. Singhvi writes with clarity, insight, and courage, presenting his arguments and opinions on various legal issues. He also provides a personal touch by sharing anecdotes and reflections from his experiences. The book is a valuable resource for anyone interested in law, politics, and society in India, as it reveals the realities and challenges of both fields. The book is also a captivating read, as it tells the stories of legal battles that shaped the nation’s history and future. From the Trenches is a book that will both entertain and teach you about law and the judiciary.
Pebble's Galaxy 
Leave a comment